See BFDI wiki for detailed canon info.

Pencil is a female contestant and a supporting protagonist on Battle for Dream IslandBattle for Dream Island Again and Battle for BFDI. She has an alliance with Match and Bubble. When Match was eliminated in Half a Loaf Is Better Than None, Pencil "substituted" Ice Cube in for her. Pencil at that point had not received a vote until the episode The Reveal, thanks to the YouTube user englishcreamcakes. In Reveal Novum, she was put up for elimination (despite winning the most points) due to the point board only holding 2 digit numbers (she earned enough points to go to 100, eventually dropping her in the low number range, of 105 to 5 points). In Rescission, Pencil was eliminated with 259 votes, giving her 9th place in the competition. She was a driver in Get In The Van. She was the first one eliminated in Battle for BFDI. She is 5' 3" tall.

In many fanfics, she is in an alliance with Match and Bubble and she is also the captain of their alliance. In the upcoming fanfic Pencil vs. Batman, Pencil is married to Pen and have six nephews and nieces (Pencil Jr., Pen Jr., Yaretzi, Zona, Qalam-Rassas, and Cil). She is also a character in RFVP parts 1, 2 and 3. She is the hero in Pencil vs. Batman.

Fan Fiction


  • Penelope Simmons (NLG343)
  • Penny (Derekblue1)
  • Cilly (Derekblue1)
  • Silly Pence-Pence (Derekblue1)
  • Abby (Jordan B (JoeJoeTheAnimator)
  • Playgo (GameboyNextGeneration)
  • Michelle Pence (ScribbledEggs)
  • Penny de Valle (Opinduver)
  • Matita Vester (Laclale/in Object CrossRoad)
  • Pina (Pinekones)
  • Paige Sachs (Tamagoyaki)
  • Phoebe LeFèvre (Ze Tossere)
  • Penny Murgatroyd (KittyFan2004)
  • Phelisha Greene (WheeliumThe2nd)
  • Penny Lunsuel (NahuelFire39)
  • Danna Joda (ImFictionalAdmin)
  • Hannah Carter (John the Addictive)
  • Jada Hughes [Roberts]
  • Penny Tippe (TheObjectThing15)
  • Paige Graphite (Hanjax70)
  • Patricia L. Mongol Bituin (Pimimyun)
  • Patricia Righter (Jokshoofficalonscratch77)


  • May 21 2002 (idk)
  • May 12, 2001 (NLG343)
  • July 30, 1992 (treyelevators)
  • June 14, 1992 (Opinduver)
  • September 27, 1999 (KittyFan2004)
  • February 28, 2009 (Pinekones)
  • August 17, 1993 (Tamagoyaki)
  • April 28, 1989 (Ze Tossere)
  • Sometime in 1992 (Infinityblade2995)
  • September 14, 1998 (TheGamerAlex2004)
  • September 15, 2000 (WheeliumThe2nd)
  • August 8, 1997 (John the Addictive)
  •  ??? (NahuelFire39)
  • July 3, 1997 (U4Again)
  • April 24, 1995 (BalloonFanThatBoialt)
  • January 31, 1991 (Shanemulrooney)
  • May 21, 2023 (EvanVizuett)
  • October 31st, 2001 (TheObjectThing15)
  • January 5, 1990 (AwesomeTails)
  • September 15, 1998 (Hanjax70)
  • March 30, 1987 (Jokshoofficalonscratch77)

Where Pencil is From

  • Beverly Hills, California
  • Gatineau, Quebec, Canada (Ze Tossere)
  • Collinsville, Illinois (Tamagoyaki)
  • Marlborough, Massachusetts (KittyFan2004)
  • New York, United States (Infinityblade2995)
  • Somewhere in Japan (WheeliumThe2nd)
  • Los Angeles, California (NahuelFire39) (Hanjax70) (Jokshoofficalonscratch77)
  • Oakbrook Terrace, IL (John the Addictive)
  • Rochester, New York (U4Again)
  • New York City, New York (MrFlamerBoy)
  • Holyhead, Wales (Shanemulrooney)
  • Objectpolis (EvanVizuett)
  • New Jersey (AwesomeTails)
  • Tondo, Manila, Philippines (Pimimyun)

Ethnic Background

  • Swedish (KittyFan2004)
  • Irish and French (John the Addictive)
  • French (Ze Tossere)
  • Filipino (Pimimyun)
  • American (Jokshoofficalonscratch77)


  • Canadian (Ze Tossere)
  • American (KittyFan2004, U4Again, Tamagoyaki, Infinityblade2995, NahuelFire39, John the Addictive, jacknjellify, Hanjax70, NLG343) (Jokshoofficalonscratch77)
  • Japanese (WheeliumThe2nd)
  • Welsh (Shanemulrooney)
  • Australian-English (AwesomeTails)
  • Filipino (Pimimyun)

Children (Pencil vs. Batman)

In Pencil vs. Batman, Pencil and Pen have six nephews and nieces.

  • Pencil Jr. is the oldest niece who is 13 years old. (No worries, time goes differently when it comes to objects.) She dated Nickel, but broke up with him shortly before the Inanimate Insanity episode The Arena of Death. She looks exactly like her mother, unsurprisingly, but instead of the three shades of orange, it is rather a gradient.
  • Pen Jr. is the second oldest brother (10 years) He looks like Pen but with a lighter shade of blue.
  • Yaretzi is one of the two 'twin sisters'. She is nearly always optimistic and has a green Y on her head to distinguish her from her sister. It apparently is Aztec for You will always be loved.(
  • Zona is the younger of the twins. She is somewhat selfish and has a red Z on her head. She was named after the neighborhood in Mexico City (Zona Rosa) where Pencil and Pen went on honeymoon. She resembles Pencil with a blue eraser and without a point, like her sister.
  • Qalam-Rassas is the second youngest. His name means 'pencil' in Arabic. (قلم رصاص). He strangely looks like a red Pen with Pencil's point.
  • Cil is the baby. His name is basically Pencil without Pen. Originally, he was a recommended character by PencilDitz in the BFDI Episode Gardening Hero. He was called 'Pencil & Pen's Baby'.

Children (ScribbledEggs)

In ScribbledEggs, Pencil has 1 baby.

BFDI Survivor

In the YouTube camp "Battle for Dream Island Survivor", or BFDI Survivor as it is usually called, Pencil is one of the contestants in the game, and is played by Mike Hagen (ChaoEpic121420, bronyboybro, bronyboy12able). However, Pencil only stayed around for 1 episode before closing her account, causing her to be eliminated. In the first Rejoin Challenge, Pencil (now bronyboybro, same person) did the challenge too late, causing her chances to rejoin to go null.

Running For Vice President (parts 1-present)

She is in team Yoylecakes. Her personality in this story is kinder and caring than her jerky attitude in BFDIA. She shows affection to Pen (Chapter 2c).

Anthony's BFDI/II Camp

In Anthony's BFDI/II Camp, she is also a contestant (as sandro shubitidze previously jay28jay2) who is eliminated at the 1st elimination and rejoined at 5C/6A.


Pencil was one of the veterans to join the game, joining the Orange Rubber Bands. After Yellow Face joined as the last contestant and Match got sent to the TLC, she had a conflict with YF, even though they were on the same team, going so far as voting for him in the 1st Cake at Stake, where they weren't even at risk of elimination. However, thanks to the illegal voting, Pencil went to the TLC, being the 1st ORB to go there. However, in Day 6, she rejoined, because Needle slapped her out after calling her Needy. However, she got eliminated AGAIN because of her slight rudeness, and not getting much screentime.

Ultimate Object World

Pencil started the show safe from elimination, but as soon as she was put up for the 1st double elimination, she got eliminated due to her personality in BFDIA, along with Match.

Battle for Emerald Island

She was nice in episode 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ,and 6.

BFDIA Randomized

Pencil was originally a contestant on Team Ice, however, in Episode 5(a) Pencil forms team freesmart with Match, and the contestants to join the team would be Book, Ruby, Match, Ice Cube, and Firey, Pencil was the team captain of Freesmart. Pencil was eliminated in Episode 10 with 3 votes.

Jacknjellify's War of The Worlds

Since she is taking a break and Objects too at night. As they saw a five of Martian Cylinder falling to forest like a shooting star. One day. She enters forest and sees five of Martian Cylinder and objects too.

Battle for BFDI

Getting Teardrop to Talk

In Getting Teardrop to Talk, Pencil was the team leader of iance. She made Bubble demoted from her alliance, and made her from a member, to bember. She told Lightning to zap Fanny since she hates jumping. Bubble then cries when Lightning electrocutes Fanny thanks to Pencil. Her team lost the challenge since jumping didn't work.

Lick Your Way to Freedom

In Lick Your Way to Freedom, Pencil was eliminated with 4,595 votes, making her the first contestant to be eliminated in Battle for BFDI, and she got sucked into Four.


  • Pencil can speak any language ever, ranging from Klingon to Esperanto to Mapuche. (iPencil.2O)
  • Pencil is the only contestant to in at or more than 5 object series.
  • Pencil has a record of going the longest time in season 1 without getting any votes, with 1 year and 3 months. However, on April 1st, 2011, her streak had been broken because englishcreamcakes casted the first ever Pencil vote. She got 37 other votes as well for episode 17.
    • She is also the last contestant to receive their first vote.
  • Pencil has the most colors, with seven different colors.
  • Sometimes, Pencil and Match's mouths are connected in only one.
  • Match is now Pencil's enemy, due to Match stealing her boyfriend (Pen).
  • Pencil commonly chants something like this: "Let him out, yeah yeah yeah! Let him out, yeah yeah yeah, so we can win the contest, so we can win the contest!"
  • She is currently the lowest ranking contestant in Battle for BFDI. But if she rejoins then Bracelety will be the lowest.
  • She will be the co-host of Object Multiplication with Paper.
  • Pencil could possibly be a very thin human, or a pencil.





The Pencil Show (Pencil 64)


  • You're Jewish? (The Best Hanuchristmas Party Ever!)
  • Oh yeah. Wrong classroom. (The Promotion)
  • I just had the strangest dream ever. Me and someone got married and had six kids! (Love at First Party)
  • Oh, this friendship is over! (War Is Over...Maybe?)
  • Hey, that's offensive to my mum! (Pencil Returns)

Names in other languages

  • German - Bleistift / Pencil
  • Turkish - Kalem
  • Spanish - Lapiz
  • Japanese - ペンシル(in borrowed word), 鉛筆/えんぴつ(in native word)
  • Italian - Matita
  • French - Crayon
  • Irish - Peann luaidhe
            Object Show Villains

Battle for Dream Island
8-Ball | Blocky | Book | Coiny | Donut | Dora | Evil Leafy | Fanny | Firey Jr. | Flower | Four | Lollipop | Match | Pencil | Robot Flower | Two

Inanimate Insanity
Knife | Nickel | Teddy Bear | MePhone4S | Toilet | Taco | MePhone5 | Trophy

Object Mayhem
Burrito | Football | Gun

Brawl of the Objects
The Hacker | Pear

Object Overload
Lighter | Toothy

Object Havoc
Lighter | Plate

Object Lockdown
Moon | Umbrella | Stop Sign | Cherry | Banana | Diamond

Object Terror
Wallet | Magazine | Smore | Printer

Object Invasion
Ethan | Lamp | Mace | Orange Juice

Paper Puppets/Paper Puppets Take 2
Knight Helmet | Plasma Ball

Yet Another Gameshow
3D-Printed Naily | Kirby Super Star Ultra

Supernova Specialization

Battle for the Respect of Roboty
8-Ball | Broboty | Epic Girl | Tweeny

Nonexistent Living
Magic Wand | Twig | Sharpener | Mug | Thermometer | Picture Frame

Entity Frenzy
Ice Tea | Chroma | Host

Object Filler
Kidz Bop 7 | Windowy 2.0 | Drummy | Club Penguin Logo | Fan

Open Source Objects
Inhaler | Holly

Galactic Conquest
Spray Paint | Star

The Insane Battle of Objects

Irrational Items

Object Show (Zojo)


Castle Wars

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.