Pie

Pie is one of the original 30 recommended characters in BFDI, who debuted in Bowling, Now with Explosions! (episode 16) as the prize at Cake at Stake.

Pie has been chosen to be one of the recommended characters who has a chance to debut in BFDI, but eventually fails to join BFDI with 7 votes only (tying with Grassy and Remote).

Pie made a second attempt and failed with 104 votes only, placing 42nd overall.

BFDI(A)
Pie's original design is more crooked and flawed, than the current one. The shaded parts are all more darker and the blue marks are much more larger. The tin in contrast has lines on it and is larger. Pie's face is on the tin.

IDFB
Unlike the previous one, Pie's current appearance is much more flawless and is more detailed. The shadings are much more lighter and there's no lines in the tin anymore, yet the blue marks are much more smaller and Pie's body in general is more smaller. Pie's face is no longer on the tin, but on the pie itself.