Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-27026386-20160525235740

This is a reboot since the last one was too disorganized. Here are the contestants that will be battling to win the name 'Best Ice Cream Ever'.
 * 1) Birthday Cake
 * 2) Broccoli
 * 3) Cookies and Creme
 * 4) Cookie Dough
 * 5) Cotton Candy
 * 6) Cream
 * 7) Granola Bar
 * 8) Grape
 * 9) Gunpowder
 * 10) Jellyfish
 * 11) Mint
 * 12) Pink
 * 13) Pumpkin
 * 14) Rainbow Sherbet
 * 15) Rocky Road
 * 16) Rose
 * 17) Tiramisu

They will be re-owned by their respective owners and they can switch characters if they want but the other owner must approve of it. Anyways the first challenge is a 'finish-the-statement' type. So here it is - You guys are characters in this story. One of you threw a party, an outdoor party in the beach, suddenly something weird happened, it was _______ (finish the statement) 